Daly and colleagues have overestimated the magnitude of the “Cinderella effect” in lethal child abuse, and underestimated the role of confounding variables in its explanation. A reply to Daly (2022)

Nobes, Gavin ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1991-1130 (2023) Daly and colleagues have overestimated the magnitude of the “Cinderella effect” in lethal child abuse, and underestimated the role of confounding variables in its explanation. A reply to Daly (2022). Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. ISSN 0096-3445 (In Press)

Microsoft Word (OpenXML) (Nobes 2023 JEPG Reply to Daly ACCEPTED) - Accepted Version Restricted to Repository staff only until 31 December 2099. Request a copy

Abstract

Nobes et al. (2019) used updated data from the same source – the British Home Office’s Homicide Index – as that used by Daly and Wilson (1994) to investigate the Cinderella effect (increased risk to stepchildren), and in particular their claim (e.g., Daly, 2022; Daly & Wilson, 1994, 2001, 2008) that stepfathers fatally assault their young children at rates more than 100 times those of genetic fathers. Nobes et al. reported much lower – though still substantial – increased risk to young stepchildren, and little or none to older children, particularly when they took the mislabeling of non-cohabiting perpetrators into account. In his Commentary, Daly (2022) largely accepts this analysis, but does not acknowledge its implications for his own findings and claims. Nobes et al. also reported that controlling for father’s age accounted for much of the remaining increased risk, and argued that this and other confounding variables are likely to explain most or all of the Cinderella effect. Daly says very little about this too, but instead responds with a series of criticisms, many of which misrepresent Nobes et al.’s account, and most of which are incorrect. Young stepchildren are at increased risk, but if stepparenthood per se (i.e., lack of genetic relatedness) contributes to the explanation, its influence is considerably less than Daly claims.

Item Type:	Article
Uncontrolled Keywords:	stepfathers,stepchildren,child homicide,filicide,cinderella effect,sdg 3 - good health and well-being,sdg 16 - peace, justice and strong institutions ,/dk/atira/pure/sustainabledevelopmentgoals/good_health_and_well_being
Faculty \ School:	Faculty of Social Sciences > School of Psychology
UEA Research Groups:	Faculty of Social Sciences > Research Centres > Centre for Research on Children and Families Faculty of Arts and Humanities > Research Groups > UEA Experimental Philosophy Group Faculty of Social Sciences > Research Groups > Cognition, Action and Perception Faculty of Social Sciences > Research Groups > Developmental Science Faculty of Social Sciences > Research Groups > Social Cognition Research Group
Depositing User:	LivePure Connector
Date Deposited:	11 Sep 2023 10:30
Last Modified:	11 Sep 2023 10:30
URI:	https://ueaeprints.uea.ac.uk/id/eprint/93020
DOI:

Actions (login required)

View Item